21/07/2021
My girlfriend at the time and I were just starting to experiment with the idea of sharing her body with another guy.
I was her first and only partner so it was an extra hot situation to me - and her too, I think. One day while messing around on the couch, I told her I want our mutual friend Tim to come over and play with her.
She reluctantly was like "ok, let's do it". We made up some rules. I made her be blindfolded and naked under a blanket on the couch.
I then called Tim right there and told him the situation. I was like "hey, Nicole and I are playing truth or dare and the dare was for you to come over and play with her".
He immediately started laughing and was like "WHAT? You're nuts. No, I'm not gonna do that." I was like "OK, see you in 10 minutes" (pretending he said yes).
I then hung up and told Nicole to get ready. We were instantly super nervous (even though only I knew he wasn't coming over). A few minutes later, while we were "waiting" for him, he called back and told me "you still want me to come? I'll be there soon".
I said "sure!". When I hung up, I said "he's at the door !!" And she said "No wait, I'm scared" but I ran up anyway to open the door.
I then proceeded to pretend we both are in the room, quiet whispers and giggling like Tim giggles (he's a stoner, and has a giggle). I slowly pulled back the covers and exposed her tits and then crazy giggled and stomped around then covered her back up.
I then whispered "come on man it's ok!" and he took the blanket totally off. Her knees were up in the air, kinda prudishly concealing herself and then "he" pryed them apart and I could hear her audibly gasp, but she held a straight face and then overcame her reluctance.
"He" then fingered her hilariously hard - trying to make sure it's a fingering that she never experienced with me - to help convince her that this was DEFINITELY not me.
She arched her back like an alien creature - i've never seen her do anything like this before. I then did the same with my tongue - did a strange lick that was def not me.
This went on for 10 minutes or so and then I walked away and "he left" out the front door. It was so convincing that she was so scared that she enjoyed herself too much and was worried I would be upset.
I'm pretty sure that day changed my life because it's those hot situations are the only thing that get me off to this day. In fact, I peruse this site daily for ideas to add to my bank.