10/11/2016
Part 2
After Caddie disappeared to the bedroom, Jeff and Mitch went through the motions and words of Mitch leaving like normal. Only instead of leaving, he quietly followed Mitch to her spare bedroom.
Jeff went into the bedroom, complimented Caddie on her outfit and then blindfolded her and left the bedroom. He went to the spare room and gave his clothes to Mitch so he would feel and smell like Jeff. Jeff then led him to the bedroom door and knocked. Mitch heard Caddie invite him in and he silently entered the room.
Jeff hurried to his home office and turned on his large screen and watched the video feed from the two spy cams that were still in place. Jeff also hit record to keep a video record of this momentous occasion.
Mitch played his part perfectly. He gently ran his hands up and down her body over her clothes and then began to carefully undress her in the same way Jeff had done. By the time Mitch had Caddie down to her bra and panties, Jeff had his cock out and was stroking it.
Jeff watched intently as Mitch removed her bra and kissed her nipples. Then Mitch removed her panties, kissing her butt just like he always did. Jeff thought to himself that he couldn’t believe he was letting this happen to his wife and that he was watching it.
Mitch stripped out of his clothes and then moved behind Caddie, nestled his very hard cock between the cheeks of her perfect tight butt and then reach around, cupped her boobs and pulled her against him. Caddie leaned her head back against him like she always did and moaned. Jeff heard her say how extra hard his cock felt tonight.
After a few moments, Mitch guided Caddie to the bed and laid her down. She spread her legs as usual and Mitch climbed between them and began kissing his way up from her feet to her pussy. When Mitch licked her pussy, Caddie responded with her usual muscle jerk. She moaned and told him how hot his breath was.
Jeff lost his load when he saw Mitch work his tongue into his wife’s pussy. Caddie moaned even louder. Mitch then moved up to her clit and licked, sucked and nibbled on it until Caddie had a strong orgasm.
Then Mitch kissed his way up to her boobs, kissed her nipples and then up to her neck and where he was in position to slide his throbbing cock into her. Jeff watched intently as Mitch slid his cock all the way into his wife’s pussy in one easy push. Mitch slowly and rhythmically slid and in and out of Caddie’s pussy just like Jeff did. Caddie moaned several times and whispered how good Mitch felt inside her
Jeff could tell when Mitch came inside his wife and watched as the two of them embraced until Mitch grew soft. Then he lifted away from her and left the room. Jeff met him at the spare bedroom and Mitch was all smiles. He quickly cleaned himself off, got dressed and quietly left, locking the front door behind him (they had keys to each other’s house).
Jeff slipped back into the bedroom, took off Caddie’s blindfold and proceeded to take his sloppy seconds like normal. They made passionate love and fell asleep in each’s arms.
In the house next door, Mitch watched the video feed and stroked himself to another ejaculation before crawling into bed.
It wasn’t until a month or so later when Jeff and Caddie were again role playing that Caddie admitted that she had been thinking of letting Mitch see her naked. Jeff asked her if she really meant it and when she said yes, he decided he would tell her that he had shown naked photos of her to Mitch. Caddie was shocked at first and then very turned on at the thought Mitch seeing her naked photos. She asked how he like the photos and Jeff told her that he stroked off to them every night and wanted to have sex with her. She hesitated and then said she might be willing to try that if it was okay with Jeff.
The next morning, Jeff decided to run the video of her and Mitch. Caddie just sat there and stared at the big screen and watched as her neighbor stripped her, touched her, kissed, licked and sucked her and then fucked her. Jeff wasn’t sure what the reaction would be but to his surprise, she asked if they could do it again sometime and not tell her when it was Jeff and when it was Mitch. She also asked Jeff to neve tell Mitch that she saw the video or knew what had happened. For the next year, Mitch switched places with Jeff at least once a month. Caddie tried afterwards to guess if it was Jeff or Mitch but in most cases she was wrong. She finally had to admit to Jeff that she really couldn’t tell.
Just as Caddie was ready to tell Mitch that she knew what had been happening, he was offered a better job in another state and moved away almost immediately. Jeff told me that the experience with Mitch really helped to bring Caddie out of her conservative shell and explore other more risqué things.