27/08/2026
I brought the idea of having sex with others up to my wife after we both realized our sex life at 41 could use some spice. She was polyamorous back in her 20s (and also bisexual) so this was something she knew, although she hadn't done it since we got married.
We made an account on AFF and had no luck for about a month, until we ended up matching with this girl who we'll call Jessica who was 27 years old.
She was skinny, pale, had long, straight blonde hair and circular glasses. I was imagining her without the pastel clothes she was wearing every time I saw her profile picture. I showed my wife and she said, as a joke, "Hope you don't run away with that chick!"
I messaged Jessica and we started chatting. I didn't know how to introduce the threesome proposal to her, especially since she looked so innocent on the outside, but when I brought it up, she actually loved it! I told her to meet us at a local diner so we could discuss what we would do before going back to our house for the main event.
When we met with her, she was extremely kind, polite, yet had a hint of shyness in her (understandable given the circumstances). We tried to put her at ease by discussing different things with her, such as triggers, hard limits, past experience, etc. She had sex plenty of times before, but she'd never done 3somes, nor had she ever had sex with an older couple before. After she said that, I remember telling her "I'll be glad to be your first." to which she blushed intensely and said "Thank you, sir."
Had we not been in public, we probably would have started fucking right then and there.
We went back to the house with Jessica and locked the front door. I started making out with her, straddling her over the couch. At the same time, my wife began taking her own clothes off and shook her huge tits in Jessica's face, asking her if she liked it. Jessica said "Yes, ma'am."
My wife told Jessica to take her clothes off, which she did. She took off her T-shirt and bra, exposing her small, but cute breasts. She was a bit insecure about the size, especially when compared with my wife's milk-jug-esque proportions, but I let her know I liked her little tits and sucked on them. I pulled her plaid skirt and panties down as she moaned intensely. We began fucking in the missionary position as my wife watched us, rubbing her pussy. I pulled out of Jessica and ripped the condom off.
I stroked myself onto her small chest and ejaculated all over it, getting some in Jessica's mouth. She smiled and licked her lips like she was eating vanilla ice cream.
My wife came in and began kissing Jessica as well, licking the cum off her body. She got on top of Jessica and positioned her pussy just above Jessica's mouth.
My wife asked her if she was ready, to which she replied in a whisper "Yes, please..." Jessica began licking my wife's beautiful, trimmed pussy. At the same time, I kissed my wife passionately.
We both shared a look that said "We made the right choice."
The rest of that night was a haze of sex, moaning, and orgasms. At the end, we all cuddled on the bed, with Jessica nestled snuggly in between me and my wife's bodies. Just before we all fell asleep, I heard Jessica whisper, "You two make me feel so safe right now."
In the morning, Jessica was already gone when my wife and I woke up. However, when I walked back into the living room, I saw her white panties laid out neatly on the couch.
I smiled and took out my phone to message her, sending her a pic of the panties she left with a smiling emoji. After a few minutes, she texted back "Can't wait to see you two again :)"
Needless to say, we've been talking about meeting with Jessica a second time.
Poster:
Open Couple