11/03/2026
Been with my wife since 2019, when she was in college. She shared an apartment with her twin sister. The first month we were dating I had mistaken the 2 when I was getting out of the shower at their apartment after going on an early morning run.
I purposefully had forgotten a towel so I could call her name to bring me a towel so we could flirt and play privately for a minute or two with her sister in the other room and not suspect anything.
What I didn't realize is that my gf (now wife) had ran to get some snacks at the convenience store for lunch. It was her sister that brought me a towel. It was still early and the hallway outside the bathroom was pretty dark and I assumed it was my gf. Instead of hiding myself being the door, I pulled her into the bathroom, I’m butt naked and hanging pretty good and asked if she “wanted to play”. There was a hesitation then she said ****** will be back any minute.
I freaked out, apologized and told her I thought she was her sister. I was so embarrassed not only because of what I said, she saw me naked. She never told my wife, it was always an inside joke. Whenever shes see a chess board, cards, and board games she would say "wanna play" and gives me the look giving me grief about the accident.
Then I was military and a few months later the sister started dating a military guy, different branch though. After college we got married and moved to my next duty station. Her sister got married as well they just moved to a new duty station last November.
A few weeks ago her sister's husband got deployed and asked to come stay with us since she didn't have many friends at his new duty station. My wife agreed, but had business trip scheduled for last week, and couldn’t reschedule. So it’s been just me and her sister.
That Sunday night after getting back from the airport dropping my wife off, her husband FaceTimed her while we were driving back. I’d never met him, so we introduced ourselves and he said my SIL had talked about me quite a bit.
He then said, 'take care of her' and the they went off video and talked for a few minutes. I couldn't tell what they were talking about but I sensed she was uncomfortable. She then asked if she could give my number to him, to which I agreed.
About an hour after we get back I get a text and it was her husband. He asked if he could call me and I said sure. So, we started talking about military stuff and how’s deployments suck.
He then brings up my wife being out of town, and how I felt being alone with his wife. I was surprised by this question and after stuttering for a second assured him that he could trust me.
He then brought up that his wife told him about the time I asked her to play. I apologized and reminded him it was an honest mistake. He then cuts me off and tells me that I’m taking it the wrong way.
He goes on tell me that she’s always had a crush on me and he’s turned on by her talking about it and he’d like to see her fuck me. At this point I can’t process this and told him I don’t know what to say. I wished him safety and told him I had to go.
The next morning he calls me again and told me he was sorry if he offended me, but the offer stood. He simply asked that he watch via FaceTime or that I send videos.
Later Monday when I got back from work I told his wife about the conversation. She then told me that she knew very nonchalantly. I then asked if he was pushing the idea. She said they’d talked about this for a week before she came here but she was afraid to bring it up.
Later that night she got on FaceTime with him and he started talking dirty to her and told her he wanted her to get naked. Within a few minutes she’s walking round the house naked talking to him occasionally looking back at me to see my reaction.
Finally she came over to the couch and started tugging my sweats. Hesitantly I pulled them off and let her start on me. After few minutes FaceTime started to lag and he told me to video it and send it to him as soon as we finished.
We did this 8 times in a 4 day window and the feeling is still surreal. One minute I’m wanting more and the next I’m trying to figure out how not to get caught.
Poster:
Rusty